Tuesday, December 23, 2025

The Huron Carol

 This is an old, old, one - credited to Jean Brébeuf in the 1600s. (Though as the singer - himself a composer - notes, the tune probably postdates Brébeuf).

It's a chant, which to me gives it an older and wilder sound.  

He sings it in both French and English. He notes there are Native words - in the Wendat language, but he felt he couldn't do that version justice as Wendat is a language basically being resurrected, and he felt there weren't enough speakers of it for him to learn proper pronunciation from


 He also notes that the Nativity story has been "reset" from the First Century Middle East to pre-colonial North America. You see this done. I am not bothered by it: the idea that Christ is for all times and all places can also sit along with the idea of "we know a little of the history so we should try to be accurate"

I am similarly not bothered by the reset of time of year (a lot of theologians thing Christ was probably actually born in the spring, and the December time is to piggyback on existing Solstice celebrations. But to me it makes sense to celebrate the coming of the Light as the light is returning to the earth in the Northern Hemisphere).

I think this is also why I like to see Nativity sets that are culturally distinct - I've seen ones from Mexico that definitely incorporate traditional art styles, and ones from Asia where the figures have Asian features, and so on.

(And the funny thing? I think of a throwaway joke in a long ago sitcom where a Black person - I seem to remember her as a "mom aged" or older woman takes a younger white person that they either taught or cared for to her church, and the younger person expresses surprise at the portrait of Jesus depicting him as a Black man, and the woman makes a sort-of joke about "well, yes, everyone sees Him as being like themselves; I bet in Kermit the Frog's church He's green" and yes, maybe there's something to that. Just as long as we remember the historical Jesus was not blonde and Northern European looking...) 

2 comments:

Joan said...

One of my favorites, but I’ve never heard this « primitive » version of it before. I only know the choral version:

https://youtube.com/shorts/WtK-RM72cL4?si=Vr7QXraZOKDNzjML

Gorski said...

Heh--like themselves--sure! Somehow a bunch of us are myopic enough not to ask why He's a light haired pale-skinned benevolent rock and roller in so much art... He may not have been sub-Saharan African black, but He didn't look like he lived by the North Sea either!

One of the theories I remember about why Christmas is in December is quite simply that it's nine months after the feast of the Annunciation... which in turn is in March bc of some pious legend that holy people died on the same date as their conception (!!). Idk where a legend like that came from... and I'm not particularly sure anymore that that's the order that happened in. Really at some level we keep the feast in December not bc the events would have been on that day like we modern folks track birthdays, but just because we need a day to keep the feast ¯\_(ツ)_/¯

Anyway, enjoyed the carol, thanks!