A video that came across my Bluesky timeline, and I've been thinking about it for a couple days:
This is something people have talked about periodically: how the rise, and now supremacy, of recorded (and now: streaming) music has replaced many people making music on their own. But again, I am a bit older, and my family was demographically older (my maternal grandmother was born in 1897) and I remember older female relatives who sang while doing housework (my grandmother usually favored hymns). And I knew people growing up who had pianos or guitars or other instruments, and they played for their own or their family's entertainment. Oh, it wasn't COMMON by the time I was a kid, but it was understood "a lot of people used to do this regularly"
And church choirs used to be more common than they are now (some churches largely dropped them during the pandemic, for safety reasons, and never really brought them back; others have "praise bands" which are, I guess individuals making music in a different style*) And I guess in some congregations there isn't really congregational singing any more?
(*I admit "praise songs" or what is sometimes derided as 7-11s - the same seven words or phrases, done rock style, repeated at least 11 times - are very much not my style; I prefer the hymns with older roots. Some hymnals have also brought in hymns from other cultures - we sing a couple that are based on (in one case) a Maori song and (in the other) an East Indian folksong, and I remember when my parents were in the choir at their church a couple times they did a South African hymn/song called Siyahamba. And I like that; I like the explicit reminder that there are people around the world who, whatever our other differences, have a big thing in common with me)
I've also thought how recently home-sewing is MUCH harder to do than it once was - unless you're in or near a large city that would have dressmaker shops. JoAnn's is gone, most of the fabric you can buy in huge areas of the country is restricted to either quilting cotton or maybe what you can mail order (the problem there, being, you can't FEEL the fabric first before buying it). And now paper patterns will be much harder to get, given that the companies have been sold off and it's not at all clear if affordable ones will still be printed.
I am old enough to remember when it was more affordable (at least for the quality) to make clothes at home than to buy them (then again: I am also old enough to remember "look for the Union Label" on clothes that were made here; now, very, very few clothes are).
And I worry a bit about the apparent decline in knitting again, after a high period from the late 1990s until shortly after the pandemic, and I DO suspect we'll lose a lot of yarn shops to tariff costs. (Maybe being online will save some of them). And magazines are mostly gone. Oh, I can still get Simply Knitting, for as long as we're allowed to get printed matter coming in from the UK without huge tariffs. And yes, online patterns are a thing, and thank God especially for places like Knitty where the patterns are explicitly peer-reviewed, and they've made a strong pledge not to use AI (there have been cases of "AI patterns" that make no sense showing up places on line......perhaps you set out to make a sweater and wind up knitting a ranch house?)
But there are also far fewer knitting books coming out than there were in the earlier 2000s, and some of the ones I see advertised online have a whiff of "might be AI" about them.
And I do worry about this a bit. One thing some of the faculty have talked about is how you can tell people who did "creative play" (for lack of a better term: I mean stuff like building with Lego, or building models, or making doll clothes) as a kid; they are more comfortable working with stuff in lab, sometimes have better fine motor skills but also *less fear* of working with physical things.
And today on Bluesky the question came up: Did your kids (or, if you're younger) have to read "whole" books in school?
And at first I was like "bwuh?" but apparently some places are just giving excerpts to read? And yes, that also used to be a thing - the old SRA system I loved a lot as a fourth and fifth grader were very short pieces, in a few cases things abstracted from longer pieces or things like a very short précis of some nonfiction topic. But we also read books, and in fact when I blew through the whole SRA box before Thanksgiving (it was supposed to last the whole year), the teacher kind of sighed and told me to pick something from the classroom library (that's how I read "Where the Red Fern Grows," which, I was probably a little emotionally young for at that point, I didn't deal well with....well, if you've read the book, you know)
We also had what was called SSR (sustained silent reading) in the early grades - at the end of the day, 15 or 20 minutes where you could bring a book from home, or use a book checked out from the school library, or a book from the classroom library, and you just read. You could sit at your desk or under your desk or on the floor, as long as you weren't disturbing anyone it was fine. I always like that because it was quiet and it was a nice cool down after the day.
But maybe that's less common now with the rise of high stakes testing where there are particular subjects that "must" be covered, and covered in the way the test will approach them? Several of my colleagues, including people 20 years my junior, have complained "the students we are getting now.....they don't READ. They're not comfortable with it, it's not something that's been expected of them" and YES I understand things like dyslexia and other LDs, but those aren't that widespread, and also, things like audiobooks work as an accommodation. These are just folks who....don't seem to do narrative stories? Or want to do a sustained deep dive into a non fiction topic?
And that's another concerning thing, and I already had a student complain about a (20 page, and not terribly complex, and most of the information was stuff I had talked about in lecture) reading I assigned them because "I'm not good with reading long things" (this is not someone with an accommodation)
And I admit, I do fear we're losing that. I don't know if that's an "elitist" concern, or if I need to "check my privilege" - but for centuries, reading in one form or another was the primary way people got information. And one thing I like about printed books is they don't change....I've seen stories in the news presented one way, and then spun another way later, or completely disappeared without a trace. And I do wonder if the people who only know what they see on tv or on TikTok are more easily....duped into things. And certainly, there's the concept some have written about, how reading fiction specifically helps grow empathy in a person (And I'd argue that's something our society seems to lack, now).
And I admit: I don't read as much as I once did. Right now, with four classes and two research projects, it's kind of a lot, and some days I don't have the energy to read more than a couple pages in SPQR (which is enormous and is going to take me a while) before I can't concentrate on it any more. I keep saying I need to make more time to read, but I have so many things (have to finish the chicken for my niece's birthday! have to practice piano! have to grade!) that seem more urgent and eat up the time.
But I do still read, at least some. And I HAVE read, there are a LOT of books I read in the past and remember.
But also, I realize more and more: I don't fit in. I'm an oddball, a weirdo. I'm the "egghead" that students called me when I was a kid, and it's hard to relate to the rest of the world even as I want to. I don't know the same pop culture other people do, nobody knows the books I do read.
And I don't know how to fix that. I miss having a group, a tribe, which I don't really, but I'm not sure the "try to make myself normal" thing I undertook in seventh grade (watching the shows - at least, the ones I was allowed to - that my classmates said they liked, listening to "top 40" instead of classical), and it really didn't help because I do have the stink of the oddball on me.
But I also worry about all of us becoming increasingly "helpless" and shackled to consumer/media culture in how things have changed - if you can't make your own clothes (because no supplies), you have to buy whatever fast fashion has churned out. And fast fashion isn't well made and doesn't last. (And now, with tariffs - it will be as expensive as "proper" clothes once were). And I admit I worry, I don't know how we fix or change any of it.